Category Archives: Current Affairs

Making the Facts Fit the Policy

The following quote is from Jay Rosen’s "Rollback" piece at Press Think:

A PressThink reader pointed me to this testimony
at a public hearing organized by Senate Democrats on the Valerie Plame
disclosures and the effect of outing an agent (Oct. 24, 2003). (Also
discussed by Talk Left.)  The speaker is Vince Cannistraro, former Chief of Operations and Analysis, CIA Counterterrorism
Center, and now a terrorism consultant. His is one of the better
descriptions I have found of that strange feature of the Bush governing
style Suskind called “a retreat from empiricism.”

CANNISTRARO: …There was a pattern
of pressure placed on the analysts to provide supporting data for
objectives which were already articulated. It’s the inverse of the
intelligence ethic. Intelligence is supposed to describe the world as
it is and as best you can find it, and then policymakers are supposed
to use that to formulate their own policies. In this case, we had
policies that were already adopted and people were looking for the
selective pieces of intelligence that would support those policy
objectives.

This describes exactly why the Downing Street memo story was so important. Bush and his honchos let it be known that they were going to war, wanted Blair and his cadre to come along for the ride, and they knew they needed "justification" to sell the whole idea to the "people."

It also ties in with something that Steven Leavitt, one of the authors of Freakonomics, says: (I’m paraphrasing) that morality is how we’d like the world to work, whereas economics can represent how it actually does work.

I know many liberals who would argue that Bush and company are anything but moral, but I tend to believe that the President truly believes in the Kool-Aid he’s trying to peddle to the rest of us (not so sure about his honchos).  What makes it scary is that because this is a moral issue for him (freedom, good vs. evil, etc.) he cannot acknowledge that he may have been, or continues to be wrong in any way. 

Another Form of “Citizens Journalism”

The aftermath of the bombings in London were caught on video and in pictures by people using the video and picture capabilities of their mobile phones.  The BBC has a collection of the videos here and discusses the "pocket journalism" here.

Dana Blankenhorn also discusses this new phenomenon here, and makes this observation about what it means to the media industry:

"This is a huge contrast to the past, where professionals delivered most of the images, and those who were lucky enough to get early shots would auction them off.

This also means that it will become increasingly difficult for disasters to "hide." Countries like Saudi Arabia have found it impossible to ban camera phones, which will now be deployed wherever news happens.

The front-end of the news business model, the payment for collecting the data, disappeared yesterday. That’s temporary.

The race will now be on among media to publicize their willingness to take such files, the addresses of such files, the wide distribution offered on the files and (what will make the difference) prompt payment for those files."

Wi-Fi Crime

A man in Florida has been charged with stealing a Wi-Fi signal in Florida (where else).  It ends up that using someone else’s signal without permission, which is classified as "unauthorized access to a computer network," is a third degree felony. From the article:

Police say Smith admitted using the Wi-Fi signal from the home of Richard Dinon, who had noticed Smith sitting in an SUV outside Dinon’s house using a laptop computer.

The practice is so new that the Florida Department of Law Enforcement doesn’t even keep statistics, according to the St. Petersburg Times, which reported Smith’s arrest this week.

Two things here: the guy can’t be too bright considering how he got caught, and the practice isn’t that new…now someone getting charged, that’s new. 

Only in Florida.

People Behaving Politely

The Winston-Salem Journal opened up comments on a story about a local Muslim group that is trying to get some land it owns re-zoned for use as a cemetery.  To be honest I expected the comments to be at least a little rough, and perhaps a tad xenophobic.  What I found were several posts, all politely written,  that mostly agreed with the idea that the Muslims should be allowed to build their cemetery as long as it meets all local regulations.

Since the paper reviews the comments I’m not sure if they pulled down any nasty comments or not, but either way it is nice to see people behaving politely online.  If the Journal did pull down or prevent the publication of some nasty letters then maybe the Journal’s policy of review is something the Greensboro News & Record should look at given the problems they are having with "trolls."

Why I Hate Being an Adult

Have been vacationing recently with the family on Emerald Isle, NC.  It is easily the most beautiful beach I’ve visited on the Atlantic coast, but why can’t I enjoy it without my first thought being, "Insurance here must be astronomical"?

What’s the first thing out of the kids’ mouths?  "Cool, look how wide the beach is…we can build a ton of sand castles" and, "The waves here are massive!"

I hate being an adult.  Especially since I have to carry the boat, chairs, tent  and other crap across the really cool, wide beach.

Epitomy of the Hard Sell

I’d heard that military recruiters were having a hard time meeting quote, but this story from the Seattle Post-Intelligencer is unbelievable.  Here’s just a taste:

Next thing Axel knew, the same sergeant and another recruiter showed
up at the LaConner Brewing Co., the restaurant where Axel works. And
before Axel, an older cousin and other co-workers knew or understood
what was happening, Axel was whisked away in a car.

"They said we were going somewhere but I didn’t know we were going all the way to Seattle," Axel said.

Just a few tests. And so many free opportunities, the recruiters told him.

He could pursue his love of chemistry. He could serve anywhere he
chose and leave any time he wanted on an "apathy discharge" if he
didn’t like it. And he wouldn’t have to go to Iraq if he didn’t want to.

At about 3:30 in the morning, Alex was awakened in the motel and fed
a little something. Twelve hours later, without further sleep or food,
he had taken a battery of tests and signed a lot of papers he hadn’t
gotten a chance to read. "Just formalities," he was told. "Sign here.
And here. Nothing to worry about."

The kid’s mom freaked out when she can’t find her boy (the recruiter confiscated his cell phone so he wouldn’t be distracted while taking tests).  She got her grown daughter to help her track him down at the recruiting station and re-kidnap him.  Then she got a lawyer and the Marines returned the paperwork and his cell phone.

It gets better in a follow up piece in which the author summarizes the responses she got from veterans to her story.  Let’s just say that some of the Marine veterans who chimed in found the kid to be a mama’s boy.  There’s also some advice from an ex-recruiter on how to handle an overly aggressive recruiter, including failing the tests on purpose and claiming to use drugs.

I think I smell a draft coming.

What Politicians Spend

I’m sure many of you have heard of this site before, but it was new to me.  OpenSecrets.org is a site that allows you to see what the President, members of Congress and political groups spent on their campaigns.  You can search by candidate, party, state, etc. 

Here are some numbers from the 2004 election overview:

Amount raised for House candidates: $696,293,352
Amount raised for Senate candidates: $488,899,357
Amount raised for Presidential candidates: $867,856,427
Total raised: $2,053,049,136

It’s just mind boggling.

Secular Humanism

Dana Blankenhorn writes a long piece on secular humanism that touches on many topics of interest in America right now.  Intelligent design, the separation of church and state, science vs. belief, etc. As usual I don’t agree with some of what he says, do agree with much of it, and think alot because of it.

A couple of paragraphs really grabbed me.  Here’s the first:

Faith is meaningless if it is compelled. If a soup kitchen feeds you,
then demands you pray to its God in order to take that soup, is your
prayer really worth anything? If a school demands your child recite a
specific prayer, to a specific God, at a specific time, in a specific
way, where is the God in that? Where is the faith in that child?

This paragraph provoked a tangential thought process that helped me articulate my problem with evangelism. It is this:

If you need to tell me, repeatedly, why your religion (notice I said religion, not God) is so great then my first instinct is to look for its weakness.  On the other hand if while having lunch together I hear you talk about the wonderful experiences you’ve had while volunteering at your church’s soup kitchen, see your eyes light up when you talk about the great people you’ve met while building homeless shelters, sense the community you feel whenever you chaperone your church’s youth group trips, I see you as a representative of all that is good with your religion.  I may not join (do I really need to for you to have fulfilled your evangelistic mission?) but I will come to believe that your church is a true community of good, of doing what God put you, us, on Earth to do.

The next part of Dana’s post that grabbed me was this:

America is also a nation of 10,000 faiths, all actively practiced, all loudly proclaimed.

We have Bahai and Buddhist temples, Shiite, Sunni and Black Muslims.

We have Maronite and Roman Catholics, Russian and Greek Orthodox. We
have Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform Jewish temples. We have a
wealth of faiths invented right here – Mormons and Southern Baptists –
as well as churches that get by merely on their ministers’ brand name…

America is the most religious nation in the history of the planet.
We’re a Christian nation, but we are also a Buddhist one, and a Muslim
one, and a Hindu one. When God hears the prayers of America, he or she
hears dozens of languages, a great cacophony. And then there are the
atheists and agnostics who either don’t know God or don’t care.

All this is worth cherishing. All this is worth savoring. All this
is worth protecting. This is our legacy, it’s what makes us special.

My thought tangent here diverted to the damage that the exclusionary aspect of many religions is doing to our society.  If you’re not with us then you’re against us.

Those same people who stand there and proclaim the greatness of their religion also preach that their’s is the only way.  If I, or you, do not join them we will not be saved.  I will be excluded.  I am an outsider.

This kind of thinking is human in that almost all people surround themselves with people like themselves.  We fear people who are different. Unfortunately many leaders understand how to take advantage of this fear. They use this fear to manipulate us for their own ends, whether it be the furthering of their particular ideology or the gain of power and influence in the secular world.

As Dana points out, the true power of America is that we accept all faiths under our umbrella.  We recognize each individual’s right to believe in their own religion, or to not have a religion.  We are inclusive, not exclusive.   We have overcome our natural fear of "others", although it has never happened quickly (ask the Irish and Italian immigrants of the late 19th and early 20th century).

America is definitely a nation of economic haves and have nots, but it is also a nation that has led the way in offering personal liberty.  It is by nature an inclusive society.

My fear right now is of those leaders that would claim America for their particular faith.  America is NOT a Christian nation, nor a Muslim nation, nor a Hindu nation.  It is a nation that accepts all of these faiths and more.  It is a scaffold that supports all religions and none.

To close the loop let me say this:  I do not want to evangelize for America, for the same reason that I don’t want someone to evangelize their religion to me.  I want to lead my life so that I can be a representative of what is good about America.  I want my actions to speak for my belief.