Notes from My Afternoon as a Non-Reporter at a Public Meeting

As I wrote last week I spent about 5-6 hours listening to people speak at the public forum regarding the proposals by WFU Baptist Medical Center to build a hospital in Advance and Novant to build one just four miles from Advance in Clemmons.  According to the Winston-Salem Journal about 700 people were there, which I think is as accurate a count as any.  Following are some notes and observations from the afternoon:

  • When I first got there I stood in the atrium outside the meeting room and watched the proceedings on a television for a few minutes.  I was holding a steno pad since I wanted to take notes and I also wanted to be prepared if I got an important business-related call.  I guess I looked like a reporter because a tall, snow-haired gentleman in a suit that probably costs more than my annual salary approached me and nodded hello while giving me the stink-eye.  I nodded back and waited for him to introduce himself.  When he didn’t I put out my hand and said, "Hi, I’m Jon Lowder."  He shook my hand and said, "Yes."  That’s when my prick-o-meter alarm started clanging.  Then he said, "You look like you might be a reporter" to which I replied, "No, I just carry this in case I get an important call."  He didn’t seem to be buying it and he just walked off and joined his colleagues from WFU.

    Just after that a nice young lady from Novant approached and asked me if I was there to speak.  I said that yes I was and she gave me a green sticker that all the Novant supporters were wearing on their chests.  I put it on my shirt, but since I hadn’t taken off my jacket you couldn’t really see it.  I went inside and found my cousin, a Novant employee, and made my way to the side of the room where she was sitting.  I decided to lean against the wall and wait until the speaker was done before disturbing anyone to sit next to my cousin and that’s when I realized that I was standing next to a reporter (I could tell by her steno notebook and the fact that she seemed to know shorthand) and when I looked up the snow-haired prick gentleman was watching me.  That’s when I decided to whip out my notebook and pretend to write furiously for a few minutes while glancing at him intermittently.  A guys got to have a little fun in life.  After he left I went ahead and sat down.

  • Listening to 150 people say essentially the same thing is very boring.  The reporter was smart and bugged out after number 20.  I was in for the long haul.
  • If I ever want to be a reporter, or even dream of being a faux-reporter, I need to learn some form of shorthand. If not I’ll be the king of paraphrasers.
  • Two paraphrases leap to mind.  First, when the folks from WFU were given their 10 minutes to respond to some of the citizen comments their VP said that they were shocked when they heard the outgoing mayor of Clemmons say that his citizens welcomed the Novant-proposed hospital and maybe his saying that is an indication of why he got his butt kicked in the election a couple of weeks back. 

    The second was from the Davie county manager who was invited by WFU to use some of their response time to share a personal story to help explain what all this is about.  He said that after they’d publicly announced the deal with WFU he was approached by Novant representatives and he asked them how they could have the gall to approach him after what they did to another local hospital (Stokes County).  He said their reply was that it was all about market share.  He then said he told them that it wasn’t about market share it was about the people of Davie County.  If this had been a Q&A I would have asked the guy if he thought WFU didn’t care about market share as much as Novant, because if they didn’t they would be building the new hospital in Mocksville or another central location in the county and not on the eastern edge that happens to be home to the county’s wealthiest component and just a stone’s throw from the western Forsyth population centers of Clemmons and Lewisville.

  • Yes I was there to back Novant, but I was also there to say that I would like to see both hospitals built and preferably for Baptist to build theirs in Mocksville near the current Davie County Hospital.  I wasn’t the only one of that opinion.
  • The guy running the PR campaign for Novant was Mike Horn of Horn & Stronach.  He’s a former mayor of Lewisville and a current town council member.  It’s probably not a coincidence that several representatives from the town council testified in favor of Novant, but they should anyway since it would be the better option for Lewisville residents (in my opinion).
  • It’s interesting seeing people who’s public lives become entwined in their private and professional lives.  Winston-Salem’s mayor gets questioned every once in a while about his dual roles as mayor and president of the Winston-Salem Alliance, and seeing a town council member like Mike Horn wearing his other hat as PR pro was also interesting.  He didn’t speak himself on behalf of Novant, but since many of the speakers had been recruited by either side (WFU or Novant) it wouldn’t be a stretch to conclude that he probably asked his fellow leaders in Lewisville and Clemmons to appear.  Again, I’m not saying anything untoward was going on, it’s just always interesting to me to see how people who serve in public office balance their duties with their private lives.
  • The people from Novant and Baptist were all well-behaved. No catcalls, no booing, only intermittent boosterism.
  • A few of the public speakers mentioned the astronomical costs of healthcare in their comments, but no one from Baptist or Novant addressed that in their responses at the end of the day.  We need a public hearing about that.
  • One’s butt tends to go numb after four hours of sitting.  And if that’s the kind of thing that’s representative of what reporters do day-in and day-out then they can have it.
  • Finally, I’ve determined that I’ll carry a steno pad where ever I go.  It scares people and it’s a lot easier to lug around than a Fancycam.

Discover more from Befuddled

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

4 thoughts on “Notes from My Afternoon as a Non-Reporter at a Public Meeting

  1. Esbee's avatarEsbee

    (Psst. Reporters also don’t get to leave their readers hanging for THREE DAYS.)
    I have pneumonia. Lovely. When I am well, we will lunch again, and I will tell you the one item that opens all doors. (No, not money.)

    Reply
  2. Unknown's avatarjimcaserta

    Is there a reason besides your cousin & proximity to Lewisville why you support Novant? Your ideal plan sounds like Baptist bulding a new hospital near the existing Davie Cty Hospital – http://www.daviehospital.org/ – and Novant building the Clemmons Hospital. I could see a new Clemmons hospital taking a lot of business away from the existing DCH, making it unviable economically, and I doubt it makes sense to build both hospitals.
    I didn’t understand all the debate, but I guess this boils down to which plan gets state approval.
    My wife is a resident at Baptist, but we’ll be using the L&D services at Forsyth in the next couple weeks.

    Reply
  3. Jon Lowder's avatarJon Lowder

    Esbee,
    Quite right and I wouldn’t have it any other way. Look forward to the secret and lunch. Hope you feel better soon.
    Lenslinger,
    I can only imagine. I haven’t broken a real sweat for money in at least 20 years and I thank my lucky stars that the greatest physical threat I face in doing my job is finger cramps.
    Jim,
    Actually, if Novant gets their hospital they’ll be closing down Medical Park currently next to Forsyth and moving those operations to Clemmons. Other factors, which can be pros and cons for either hospital:
    1. If the Davie hospital is built it will have an L&D function. The Clemmons won’t.
    2. Something like 63% of the patients in the “service area” as they described it are in the Novant network. Makes the Clemmons hospital more convenient for the majority of folks.
    3. In looking at the traffic situation I think that, ironically, having the hospital in Clemmons will have less of a negative impact on the area. Novant retained a traffic engineer whose firm came to the conclusion that there will be significant traffic increases for Harper Road if either hospital is built. From a purely selfish standpoint I’d rather see a hospital built than another retail operation, which would be a distinct possibility in Clemmons.
    Honestly, I think it’s a win-win for the area if either hospital gets built. I think its a better scenario for Davie County if the new hospital for Baptist is built in Mocksville because it will serve points west. In the long run I think they’ll do fine because a modern facility will attract patients from the western region that are currently going to Iredell or into Winston for such things as labor and delivery and other procedures.
    FYI, I have a couple of relatives that work at Baptist too.
    And congrats on the new one and hope all goes well and without complications.

    Reply

Leave a comment