Category Archives: Piedmont-Triad

Two Papers Better Than One

Wow, I have to say I’m kind of amazed at the replies I’ve gotten to my last post .  It was really cool to hear from the folks at the Greensboro News & Record and in particular from the folks at the Winston-Salem Journal. Click here to see their comments.  Actually, it’s really cool knowing that someone is reading this thing at all.

Anyway, here are a couple of final thoughts on the Triad newspapers, at least for now:

  • I think it is absolutely vital that the Triad continue to have two quality newspapers, no matter what form they take.  I used to deliver the Washington Star in D.C. and my mom was an avid Washington Post reader, so I got to see the advantage of having two good papers in town.  (The Star’s sports and opinion sections kicked the Post’s tail, and it was the last afternoon paper I can remember reading.) Then the Star went belly up and D.C. became a one "voice" town.  (The Washington Times came along a few years later, but it’s really a conservative mouthpiece that makes the Posts liberal inclinations look balanced.)  Let’s just say that with a newspaper monopoly the region would suffer because:
  • You get one high-profile editorial viewpoint for the entire region, which can lead to a true feeling of exclusion for a large part of the populace.
  • You get less coverage of local issues.  The press, the Fourth Estate, is a vital part of the "balance of powers" and without in-depth coverage of local issues you leave the door open for opportunists.
  • Competition keeps people hungry; without it you get stagnation and little or no innovation.
  • I think both papers are excellent.  Call it a big city bias, but I really expected to get sub-par papers when I moved here.  They have been anything but.  I honestly think that the Journal is a better paper than the Washington Post, and as far as I can tell so is the News & Record.  Sure they inhabit different strata in the media landscape, but the Journal and N&R do a better job in their space than the Post does in its space.
  • Last, it truly is imperative for both newspapers to get serious about expanding their domain from paper to multi-media.  I’ve heard/read some comments about how the current hubaloo is a repeat of the death nell that was tolled for newspapers with the advent of local TV news. That’s a bunch of hogwash if for no other reason than because the landscape is changing for TV news too! 

    What we are seeing is a change in the living patterns of most Americans.  How the average 25 year old gets her information is radically different from her parents.  How many 50 year olds IM on a regular basis?  How many utilize the text messaging on their phones?   How many 25 year olds actually pick up a newspaper on a regular basis?  How many 25 year olds watch the news?  How many 50 year olds have a news feed on their computer? Yet they can all relate to the same big stories.  Why?  Because the news is the same, only the delivery is different.

    The message then is that for newspapers to remain relevant, to return to a growth mode from the atrophy mode which they’ve been living in, and to retain their influence, they must find their audience wherever the audience wants to be found.

    And they should not lose sight of the fact that they still hold a tremendous strategic advantage that is very hard for any upstart to overcome: they have the feet on the street with the contacts and institutional knowledge that they’ve developed over the decades.  It would be a shame if it were to go to waste.

My Hometown Paper?

This is something that’s been on my mind:

I live in Winston-Salem. I have the Winston-Salem Journal delivered every morning.  But I don’t feel like I know anyone there.  The paper doesn’t have a "voice",  at least not one that I can hear.  The closest thing to its voice is the editor’s column in the op-ed section.

In fairness to the Journal I think that the "voice" issue is the same for the vast majority of newspapers.  But unfortunately for the Journal they happen to be juxtaposed with the Greensboro News & Record. The N&R is making national (maybe even international) headlines, at least in the publishing sector and the nascent blogosphere, because it is embracing the newest in publishing paradigms: the blog.

At last count the N&R has five blogs: one written by the editor John Robinson, another written by Lex Alexander (I think he’s their online guru), another titled Inside Scoop, a sports blog written by multiple sports staffers, and finally The Chalkboard blog which covers local education stories.

I get all of the N&R blogs via RSS.  I don’t get their paper…yet.  But I still feel closer to the N&R, and in a way I feel it is my hometown paper.  And I think it’s going to eat the Journal’s lunch if the folks at the Journal don’t act fast.  Here’s why:

1. Via it’s blogs the N&R has been getting direct feedback from it’s audience (notice I didn’t say readers) about how they would like to see their "paper" evolve in the future.  The N&R is doing a fantastic job of helping their audience take ownership of the paper.  This is huge because…

2. Paper circulation is on its last legs as the defining metric for local newspaper companies.  They are going to have to morph to survive;  there will probably be paper for the foreseeable future, but it’s role as the core entity for the company is declining rapidly.  To morph the newspaper needs to know what it’s audience wants and then create it.  N&R is doing that, and in the process they are replacing the monologue with a dialogue.

3. N&R already owns two thirds of the Piedmont Triad region (Greensboro & High Point).   Denizens of Winston-Salem see themselves as quite distinct from the denizens of Greensboro, which is very similar to the attitude of Northern Virginians to Suburban Marylanders in the D.C. area that I recently fled.  Anyway, it would probably pain the editor at the Journal (I have no idea what his/her name is) to know that I feel like I’m on a first name basis with the editor of the Greensboro News & Record (Hi John!).  If I happen across a hot story or issue, who do you think I’m going to ping with it?

4. The future for newspapers is integrated media.  I have no idea what the mix will be, but it’s going to be some combination of paper, internet, video, audio and interactive media. 

My brother works for a major newspaper publishing company and he pointed out to me years ago that the real money for community papers is in classifieds.  At the time his company wasn’t too worried about the internet because it was a glogal entity.  Enter Craigs List.  Oops.

My point is that newspapers are sitting on the cusp of something big and they will either thrive or die.  Right now they still own a healthy part of the audience, but they need only look at their declining circulation to know that the audience share is shrinking.  They have to act now.  N&R is doing that, and they are doing it right.

5. Last point.  I hear from the N&R several times every day, all via their blogs.  I hear from the Journal in the morning and that’s it.  I used to check their website for updates, but rarely saw them.  (Honestly their site stinks).  As a result I know more about Greensboro’s city council than I do about Winston-Salem’s.

So for now I’d say that the N&R is my hometown paper.  It’s not too late for the Journal, but they better act fast or it will be.  I’d love to write the editor and share some ideas…anybody have a name for me?

Greensboro’s Newspaper Looks to the Future

This is a link to a fascinating report prepared for the Greensboro News & Record.

I don’t even want to excerpt it because I won’t do it justice.  Suffice it to say that they are being VERY forward thinking and open to new ideas.  Enough so that they are being cited throughout the "blogosphere" by some pretty influential media types. 

Most impressive is the fact that the "suits" at the GNR are seriously working to implement the recommendations of the report and they are doing so publicly.

If you have any interest in the (fast-vanishing) newspaper business, and are intrigued by "little guy schooling the big boys" stories you should definitely read this.

FYI, cross-posting to my Practical Ink publishing blog.